Not all product certificates, statements, appraisals, declarations and marketing claims carry the same regulatory or technical weight.
This guide compares common New Zealand building product certification, appraisal, technical-evidence and supplier-assurance pathways by legal status, independence, scope and practical strength for Building Code confidence, council assessment, professional specification and product-risk reduction, with a specific WaterMark note where it is relevant to plumbing and drainage product evidence.
A strong evidence document is current, traceable, product-specific, independently assessed where appropriate, clear about scope and limitations, and matched to the standard or Building Code clauses being claimed.
For composting toilets and onsite wastewater products, the question is not just whether a supplier has “a certificate”. The real question is what type of evidence it is, what it covers, what it does not cover, and whether it applies to the exact product and installation pathway.
Strong marketing can make very different evidence types look similar. A branded statement, a supplier declaration, an independent appraisal, a standards-based product certification and a CodeMark certificate are not the same thing. The purpose of this page is to give those documents their proper place in the evidence hierarchy.
This is a practical comparison of product-evidence pathways, not a legal opinion and not a fixed mathematical ranking. Scope controls everything. A narrow but current test report can sometimes answer a specific risk question better than a broad but poorly matched statement, while statutory certification or recognition can carry a specific legal effect within its defined scope.
| Evidence position | Evidence type | Examples | What it means | Practical position | Practical evidence value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Statutory product certification | CodeMark product certificate | CodeMark New Zealand certificate issued by a registered Product Certification Body | Statutory product certification pathway. A BCA must accept it where current, valid and used within certificate scope and limitations. | Mandatory within scope | Highest tier. Closest to a pre-accepted product compliance route within certificate scope. |
| Statutory product recognition | Approved Products Certified Overseas / recognised WaterMark products | MBIE recognition notice for an overseas-certified product. Current WaterMark recognition notices cover selected plumbing and drainage product categories named by MBIE. | Statutory recognition pathway. Recognised products are deemed to comply and must be accepted by BCAs when used as intended, within recognition conditions and limitations, and with required technical information. | Mandatory within scope | Top-tier evidence only for the product category and scope named in the recognition notice. This is not a blanket approval for all WaterMark products and not a whole onsite wastewater treatment-system approval. |
| Direct third-party standards certification | SAI Global StandardsMark™ / third-party standards certification | SAI Global 5 Ticks StandardsMark, product certification to AS/NZS standards, AS/NZS 1546 series certification | Independent product certification against a nominated standard or scheme, usually involving audit, testing and schedule control. | Very strong product evidence | Very strong product-standard evidence where the exact model is listed and the nominated standard matches the technology. Especially strong where the certification is to the exact relevant product standard, such as AS/NZS 1546.2:2008 for Waterless Composting Toilets. |
| Third-party plumbing / drainage certification | WaterMark certification without NZ recognition notice | WaterMark-certified plumbing or drainage product that is not covered by a current MBIE recognition notice, or is being used outside a recognition notice scope. | Strong Australian plumbing/drainage product certification evidence, but not automatically a New Zealand deemed-to-comply pathway unless the product is covered by a recognition notice or another NZ compliance route. | Strong supporting certification | Useful for plumbing and drainage components. It should be checked against the WaterMark certificate, product category, WaterMark schedule, NZ recognition notice, Building Code clauses and installation scope. |
| Independent Product Appraisal | BRANZ Product Appraisal | BRANZ Appraisal for a building product or system | Independent technical appraisal with strong New Zealand market recognition. BRANZ is a major building-science, appraisal and product-information name in New Zealand, but an appraisal is still not mandatory BCA acceptance. | Strong independent appraisal | Very strong New Zealand building-science, appraisal and product-information recognition. Still sits below direct standards certification where the core question is conformity to the exact nominated product standard. |
| Independent Product Appraisal | BEAL Product Appraisal | BEAL Product Appraisal | Independent technical appraisal of a product or system. Strong evidence if current, complete and matched to the claimed use. | Strong independent appraisal | Strong independent appraisal evidence. Sits below direct standards certification where the question is direct product conformity to a nominated product standard. |
| Independent Technical Statement | BEAL Technical Statement | BEAL Technical Statement | A technical statement or opinion-style document. It can help organise evidence and explain compliance logic, but it is not a Product Appraisal unless expressly issued as one. | Supporting technical evidence | Useful supporting evidence where it is a genuine third-party technical statement, but below full appraisal and standards certification. |
| Structured supplier assurance | Product Technical Statement (PTS) / supplier assurance | Supplier-prepared PTS, consultant-assisted PTS, PASS Product Assurance Supplier Statement (PTS) or similar supplier assurance document | Structured product information and compliance summary. A PTS can be prepared by the supplier/manufacturer or with external assistance, but it does not replace the actual evidence behind the claim. | Supporting supplier assurance | Low-value supporting evidence by itself. A Product Technical Statement or supplier-assurance document can help organise information, but it does not replace testing, appraisal, StandardsMark, CodeMark, WaterMark recognition, or project-specific BCA assessment. |
| Supplier / manufacturer declaration | SDoC / manufacturer declaration | Supplier Declaration of Conformity, manufacturer declaration, self-declared technical file statement | Supplier-authored declaration. It may help explain the claim but has limited independent value unless supported by testing, QA and scope control. | Supplier-authored evidence | Weak by itself. Can support a technical file, but should not be marketed as equivalent to appraisal, StandardsMark, WaterMark recognition or CodeMark. |
| Product information / disclosure | BPIR, warranty, manuals and marketing claims | Building Product Information Requirements disclosure, warranty terms, manuals, brochures, website claims, sales sheets | Product information and customer disclosure material. BPIR can reference certification evidence, but it is not certification itself. | Information, not certification | Expected product information. Useful for transparency and installation support, but not proof of certification on its own. |
A fixed score such as “82/100” can imply a formal legal or regulatory weighting methodology that does not exist. The more useful comparison is the evidence type’s legal status, independence, exact scope, technical basis and relevance to the question being assessed. A statutory certificate may carry mandatory acceptance within a narrow scope, while a directly relevant independent test can sometimes answer a specific performance question more clearly than a broader document.
The evidence types below are not interchangeable. Some have a specific statutory effect, some provide strong independent technical evidence, and others mainly organise or communicate supplier information. The exact document, scope and proposed use still control how useful each item is.
Top-tier statutory product certification. A current and valid CodeMark certificate must be accepted by the BCA when the product or method is used within the certificate scope and limitations.
Top-tier where an MBIE recognition notice applies. Recognition notices can cover selected WaterMark-certified plumbing and drainage product categories, but only within the product type, scope, conditions and limitations stated in the notice.
Strong product-standard certification where the actual product model is listed and the nominated standard matches the technology. For Waterless Composting Toilets, AS/NZS 1546.2:2008 is the key product standard.
Strong plumbing and drainage product evidence, but not automatically a New Zealand deemed-to-comply pathway unless the product is covered by an MBIE recognition notice or another NZ compliance route.
High-recognition New Zealand product appraisal evidence. Strong for designers, councils and specifiers, but still an appraisal rather than mandatory CodeMark acceptance.
Strong independent appraisal evidence where current, complete and matched to the claimed use. It sits above technical statements and PTS-style supplier assurance.
Useful technical statement or opinion-style document. It can help explain compliance logic, but it is not the same as a full Product Appraisal.
Low-value supporting evidence by itself. A Product Technical Statement or supplier-assurance document can help organise information, but it does not replace testing, appraisal, StandardsMark, WaterMark recognition, CodeMark, or project-specific BCA assessment.
Supplier-authored evidence. Can support a technical file, but should not be marketed as equivalent to independent appraisal, StandardsMark, WaterMark recognition or CodeMark.
Useful product information and disclosure material, but not certification by itself. These documents may reference stronger evidence; they do not replace it.
WaterMark is an Australian plumbing and drainage product certification scheme. In New Zealand, selected WaterMark-certified products can have high compliance value where MBIE has issued an Approved Products Certified Overseas recognition notice for the product category.
WaterMark is included here for completeness because it can be relevant to plumbing and drainage product evidence. It is not a general certification pathway for every building product and should not be confused with product certification for complete onsite wastewater treatment systems under the AS/NZS 1546 series.
MBIE has existing recognition notices for selected overseas-certified products and has also been consulting on proposed amendments and additional WaterMark recognition. A consultation document is not itself a recognition notice. The current MBIE recognition-notices register must be checked to confirm whether the exact WaterMark certificate, product category, conditions and Building Code clauses are currently recognised.
Where a current MBIE recognition notice applies, the product sits near the top of the evidence scale. BCAs must accept the recognised product when it is used as intended, within the notice conditions and limitations, and supported by the required technical information.
WaterMark certification can still be strong plumbing or drainage product evidence, but it is not automatically a New Zealand deemed-to-comply pathway unless the product is covered by a recognition notice or another compliance route.
WaterMark should be checked against the exact certificate, product category, recognition notice, Building Code clauses, installation scope, conditions and limitations. It is strongest where the claim is for the certified plumbing or drainage product itself.
WaterMark should not be treated as approval for a whole sanitation system, whole onsite wastewater treatment system, land-application design, or site-specific wastewater design. Those matters usually need separate product evidence, standards evidence, design evidence or consent assessment.
New Zealand also has statutory building-system pathways that should not be confused with ordinary product certification or appraisal. BuiltReady is a modular-component manufacturer certification scheme. A Building Consent Authority must accept a current manufacturer certificate as evidence that the covered modular component complies with the Building Code when it is used within the manufacturer’s certified scope and limitations.
MultiProof is a national multiple-use approval for standardised building plans and specifications. It can streamline repeated building-consent applications, but it is not product certification for a composting toilet, plumbing component or onsite wastewater treatment unit.
BuiltReady and MultiProof can have strong statutory effects for the building work they cover, but they answer different questions. They should therefore be understood alongside CodeMark and Approved Products Certified Overseas as part of the wider New Zealand building-assurance system, rather than treated as substitutes for product evidence against AS/NZS 1546.2:2008.
For Waterless Composting Toilets, the relevant product standard is AS/NZS 1546.2:2008 – On-site domestic wastewater treatment units – Waterless composting toilets. That is different from the standards for septic tanks and AWTS units.
The toilet model should be supported by model-specific evidence, product-standard evidence where available, installation instructions, capacity assumptions, ventilation requirements, maintenance obligations and end-product handling information.
Even strong product evidence does not automatically approve the building, greywater, urine/liquid disposal, land application, maintenance arrangement, user load or council consent pathway for a specific site.
Urine diversion itself is not the issue. In residential or fixed-building applications, the separated urine/liquid stream needs an accepted disposal or treatment pathway. A removable bottle may be suitable in RV/mobile contexts, but should not be treated as a complete residential wastewater solution without project-specific acceptance.
A third-party product certification should not be treated as a marketing claim. Where a current certificate identifies the certificate holder, nominated standard, product models, scope, issue date and expiry date, it should carry meaningful evidential weight.
Additional information may still be needed where the certificate does not answer the site-specific question, Building Code clause, installation condition, use load, wastewater pathway or consent issue being assessed. If further evidence is requested, the remaining gap should be identified clearly.
The better question is whether the certificate, schedule, standard, manuals and project-specific design together provide reasonable grounds for the proposed use.
Is it CodeMark, an MBIE recognition notice for an Approved Product Certified Overseas, StandardsMark, WaterMark, a full product appraisal, a technical statement, a Product Technical Statement (PTS), supplier assurance document or supplier declaration?
If WaterMark is claimed, is the product covered by a current MBIE recognition notice, or is it only an Australian WaterMark certificate being used as supporting evidence?
Is the document current, public, traceable and within its expiry date?
Does it identify the exact product model, model schedule, scope and limitations?
Does it map to the relevant Building Code clauses or the relevant product standard?
Does it rely on independent testing, standards-based certification or only supplier statements?
Does it match the intended use: RV, temporary, residential, public facility, commercial or fixed building?
Does it address the full system: solids management, urine/liquid disposal, ventilation, maintenance and end-product handling?
WCTNZ® can help customers, designers, wastewater engineers, architects, builders and councils understand the product evidence, certification level and likely documentation pathway for a proposed composting toilet or onsite wastewater project.
View current WCTNZ® certification areas, model schedules and product-evidence information.
Understand the difference between product evidence, residential legality, consent, licensed work and the complete sanitation arrangement.
Building consent, resource consent, sewered sites, greywater and project-team responsibilities.
Why self-built residential toilet systems create additional product-development, evidence, licensed-trade and consent risk.
This page is based on public-source guidance from MBIE / Building Performance, Building CodeHub, Standards New Zealand, BRANZ, BEAL and Intertek SAI Global, including MBIE recognition notices for selected WaterMark-certified plumbing and drainage products, together with practical product-evidence and consent-pathway experience. Always check current certificates, registers, scheme rules and product scopes before relying on a document.
WaterMark Certification Scheme — Intertek SAI Global NZ »
Water and plumbing product certification — Intertek SAI Global NZ »